In January 1909, panic swept across New Jersey and Pennsylvania. For one terrifying week, hundreds of people reported seeing a winged creature with hooves, glowing eyes, and a piercing cry. Trolley cars were attacked, schools closed, and vigilante groups took to the woods in search of the beast. Was it mass hysteria, mistaken identity, or a genuine encounter with the legendary Jersey Devil? In this episode, we revisit the extraordinary wave of sightings that cemented the Jersey Devil as America’s most famous cryptid.